How Do Managers Manage Conflict
Increase Employee Engagement with Effective Conflict Management
Tuesday, September 29, 2026
Effective managers don't take sides in a dispute. They facilitate resolution. To resolve employee conflict productively, act as an objective mediator: listen actively to all perspectives, separate personal friction from the underlying operational issue, and guide your team toward a concrete, mutually agreed-upon action plan.
Easy, right?
This takes serious skills!
When we look around, it appears that “conflict is the new black.” Rage-baiting and divisiveness have seemingly become the rule, not the exception.
“Conflict is inevitable, but combat is optional.”
As online survey providers with over 30 years of experience working with companies of all sizes, we can assure you that conflict – unaddressed and unmanaged – is a top employee engagement killer. As conflict rises, productivity plunges. So you need leaders and managers who can effectively manage humans (who tend to gravitate toward conflict).
What is conflict management?
HBR writes, “Conflict management is a practical framework for handling workplace disagreements by depersonalizing issues and turning tension into productive collaboration.”Is that too much to ask?
Not at all. Conflict is human. And it doesn’t have to be negative. That said, gone unchecked, it can kill employee satisfaction, engagement, and productivity. As fun as it is to watch The Bear and The Morning Show, we can all agree none of us want to work there (bring on Ted Lasso any day!). Great leaders are masters of managing conflict. Here’s how they do it.
Elevate Your Leadership Team
Schedule a free demo of our 360 Feedback Survey. Develop your managers to improve their conflict management skills.
Schedule Your Free DemoWhat are the 5 Steps of Conflict Management?
Identify the source
Look beyond the initial incident
Request solutions
Find common ground
Implement an agreement
How do great leaders and managers implement these steps to create a healthy workplace culture?
Identify the source:
You can’t solve a problem without knowing what it is. (That seems obvious, and it’s also common for managers and leaders to fall into the “fixer trap”, barreling ahead without taking the time to diagnose the issue). Identifying root causes of conflict leads to long-term solutions and improved results. So, it’s time to Hercule Poirot it.
Steps to Identify Root Causes of Conflict:
- Listen (without interrupting) — focus first on feelings, then listen for the facts.
- Observe behavior patterns
-
Ask probing questions: Who, What, When, Where, Why?
- "When did you first notice this issue?"
- "What solutions have you and your team tried to implement?"
- "What makes you feel [the way you feel]?"
-
Use the 5 Whys technique to drill down:
(Developed by the Toyota Production System, this technique is highly effective for getting to the bottom of a conflict.)
- Write a problem statement
- Ask why the problem exists
- Ask why four more times: Take each new answer and ask why that specific condition occurred
Look Beyond the Incident
Don’t dwell on the conflict and those first emotions. Take the time to understand what these surface emotions mean. Oftentimes, conflict comes from miscommunication or misinterpretation of a situation. Uncover these perspectives.
Request Forward-Thinking Solutions
Slip into problem-solving mode. Instead of finger-pointing, work with your staff and ask everyone to propose practical, concrete ways to resolve the problem. By focusing on solutions, you redirect energy into constructive collaboration.
This isn’t a zero-sum game
When discussion solutions, identify common ground to bring people together, not drive a bigger rift. Yes, we know that right now conciliation isn’t something we see often, especially on our national stage, but, really, we’re a lot more similar than different. Your staff all want a healthy place to work. They all want to do good work. This isn’t about finding a winner or a loser, but securing a fair, cooperative outcome where everyone feels invested in the path forward.
Formalize the Agreement and Follow Up
A resolution is only as good as its execution. Establish clear next steps, put the agreed-upon solutions into motion, and schedule regular check-ins. Consistent follow-up ensures accountability and prevents old conflicts from resurfacing.
Conflict is inevitable. How we approach conflict and set a standard for dealing with conflict in the workplace can make an incredible difference in employee engagement and performance. Teaching a team to handle conflict starts with management embracing key conflict management skills. These skills arm a manager or senior leader with the right tools to enter what seems like a battle and have everyone come out winning.
RECENT BLOG POSTS
Tuesday, September 29, 2026
How Do Managers Manage Conflict
Tuesday, September 22, 2026
Tuesday, September 15, 2026
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
Tuesday, August 18, 2026
Tuesday, July 28, 2026
Tuesday, July 7, 2026
Tuesday, June 23, 2026